Safe working conditions are inseparable from the right to life. In the context of India's hazardous small-scale industries, examine the regulatory and structural factors that compr

GS2 Government Policies
Safe working conditions are inseparable from the right to life. In the context of India's hazardous small-scale industries, examine the regulatory and structural factors that compromise industrial safety, and suggest measures to reconcile worker protection with livelihood security.

Examine

  • 15 marks
  • 8 min
  • 250 words
  • Hard

The Hindu

Read article →

1. Introduction

The right to life under Article 21 encompasses safe and humane working conditions. Yet, in India’s hazardous small-scale industries (fireworks, mining, chemicals), safety deficits persist due to structural and regulatory gaps.

2. Factors Compromising Industrial Safety

  • Informalisation of workforce: Contract and migrant workers lack training, documentation, and legal protection.
  • Fragmented regulatory coverage: Small units often fall below thresholds of stringent safety laws, escaping oversight.
  • Weak enforcement capacity: Inadequate inspections, understaffed labour departments, and corruption dilute compliance.
  • Cost pressures and low margins: Owners prioritise survival over investment in safety infrastructure.
  • Lack of awareness and training: Workers are often unaware of risks, safety protocols, or rights.
  • Supply chain outsourcing: Large firms shift hazardous processes to small units, diffusing accountability.
  • Poor urban planning: Clustering of hazardous units in dense residential areas amplifies risks.

3. Regulatory Framework and Gaps

  • Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions (OSH) Code, 2020: Consolidates laws but excludes many small establishments through thresholds.
  • Inspector-cum-facilitator approach: Emphasises compliance over deterrence, potentially weakening enforcement.
  • Limited local governance role: Weak coordination between labour, industrial, and municipal authorities.

4. Measures for Balancing Safety and Livelihood

  • Universal safety standards: Gradual extension of basic safety norms irrespective of firm size.
  • Cluster-based regulation: Common safety infrastructure (testing labs, storage, waste disposal) for small units.
  • Capacity building: Training programs, certification, and awareness campaigns for workers and employers.
  • Incentivised compliance: Subsidies, tax benefits, or credit access for safety upgrades.
  • Strengthened inspections: Use of technology (digital audits, GIS mapping) alongside accountable enforcement.
  • Supply chain accountability: Mandating due diligence by larger firms sourcing from small units.
  • Social security nets: Insurance and compensation mechanisms to protect workers’ livelihoods.

5. Conclusion

Ensuring industrial safety in small-scale sectors requires a balanced approach that strengthens regulation and enforcement while supporting enterprises, aligning worker protection with sustainable livelihoods.